A Database for Triticeae and Avena
UNIVERSITY OF AGRICULTURAL SCIENCES, VIENNA
Department of Plant Breeding, Gregor Mendel Str. 33, A-1180 Vienna, Austria.
G. Stift and T. Lelley.
In this communication, we report on a fast and simple method for isolation of DNA from one-half of a wheat grain. The procedure gives high-quality DNA and good yield that is useful not only for RAPD analysis, but also for amplifications with specific primers. A chloroform extraction is not needed. The protocol described here is a modification of a method published by Benito et al. (1993).
The method.
Discussion. For breeders, obtaining marker-based information as soon as possible, i.e., before beginning large experiments (crossing or selfing) is often of great advantage. With this method of DNA extraction for a PCR-based analyses, this information can be obtained from the seed before beginning an experiment. Judging from the results of the marker study, an experiment can be stopped or rearranged, avoiding loss of time. The part of the grain with the embryo is saved, thus after analyzing the DNA of a special grain, it is possible to use the embryo for further breeding purposes. The amount of DNA that we obtained depended on the size of the seed and varied between 2002,400 ng. If the 65°C incubation time is extended from 10 min to 1 hr, twice the yield of DNA is possible. Comparing this protocol to the original method of Benito et al. (1993), we found no significant difference in the yield of DNA. However, the results from PCR with the method of Benito et al. were unsatisfactory in our laboratory, possibly due to the high salt content in the resulting DNA. Therefore, the following modifications were used: proteinase K was added at the beginning of the isolation procedure to help destroy cell walls, RNaseA as added tp eliminate RNA, and two alcohol washes were added at the end of the procedure. This protocol has been used successfully in several experiments by Stachel et al. (2000).
References.
Introduction. Bread wheat varieties with the T1BL·1RS wheat-rye translocation are grown world wide and have been the subject of numerous scientific investigations over the past two decades (Graybosch 2001). The translocated rye chromatin (1RS) provides disease and pest resistance to the host wheat variety (McIntosh 1983, Sebesta et al. 1995) and improves yield potential and contributes wide adaptation to the crop (Rajaram et al. 1983, Villareal et al. 1995). At the same time, however, it reduces bread-making quality (Zeller et al. 1982, Dhaliwal et al. 1987, Graybosch et al. 1993, Fenn et al. 1994).
After studying the HMW-glutenin composition of a large number of breeding lines under registration in the Hungarian and Austrian Varietal Testing Authorities, we detected a number of lines that were heterogeneous for T1BL·1RS. From these advanced breeding lines, sister lines with and without the translocation were selected, which we consider to be nearly isogenic, and we tested them in field trials under different climatic and edaphic conditions.
Materials and methods. Field trials were made with six pairs of NILs, with and without the T1BL·1RS translocation. The material was sown in 10-m2 plots in two replications. In 199798, the lines were grown at five locations representing the widest possible range of environmental conditions for growing wheat in Austria. In 199900, they were grown at the same five locations as before and at one additional location in the southeastern Hungary, which represented a very dry, hot environment.
Results. A combined analysis of the data yielded the following results. In this material, the translocation significantly increased grain yield, especially through increased spikelet number and 1,000-kernel weight (Table 1). The effect of the translocation on plant height between the NILs also proved to be significant. The height reduction of the T1BL·1RS translocation plants (~5 cm) was connected with better resistance to lodging. Lines with the translocation had higher hectoliter weights, but the difference was not significant. A significant difference also was found in all quality traits, protein content, sedimentation value, wet-gluten content, and SDS gel protein. Lines with the translocation proved to be inferior for these traits (Table 1).
Trait | T1BL·1RS | 1B | Difference (%) | F-test |
---|---|---|---|---|
Yield (t/ha) | 6.37 | 6.10 | 4.52 | 30.45*** |
1,000-kernel weight (g) | 42.71 | 42.07 | 1.52 | 9.37** |
Hectoliter weight (kg) | 77.90 | 77.67 | 0.30 | 1.57 |
No. spikelets/spike | 19.89 | 19.53 | 1.85 | 40.27*** |
No. seeds/spike | 45.19 | 44.03 | 2.62 | 10.86** |
No. seeds/spikelet | 2.28 | 2.26 | 0.84 | 0.21 |
Spike length (mm) | 82.09 | 85.86 | - 4.39 | 133.01*** |
Spike density | 24.30 | 22.84 | 6.38 | 164.51*** |
Plant height (cm) | 87.48 | 93.11 | - 6.05 | 153.27*** |
Lodging resistance | 1.42 | 1.90 | - 25.04 | |
Maturity | 4.63 | 4.83 | - 4.29 | |
Powdery mildew | 2.41 | 2.55 | - 5.61 | |
Leaf rust | 3.33 | 3.28 | 1.60 | |
Protein content (%) | 14.70 | 15.08 | - 2.53 | 60.43*** |
Wet gluten content (%) | 34.35 | 34.97 | - 1.75 | 23.42*** |
Sedimentation value (cm3) | 51.37 | 56.21 | - 8.61 | 66.84*** |
SDS Gel protein (mm) | 4.90 | 5.80 | - 15.47 | 107.42*** |
For all traits except the number of seeds/spike, a highly significant
translocationbackground interaction was found (Table 2).
The interaction of the translocation with the environment was
not significant for yield. In nine out of eleven environments,
the translocation lines surpassed in yield isogenic lines lacking
the translocation.
Variance component | df | Yield | 1,000-kernel weight | Hectoliter weight | Spikelets/ spike | Seed/ spike | Height | Protein content | Sedimentation value | SDS gel protein |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Replication (L*Y) | 10 | 4.4*** | 2.45* | 3.29*** | 8.74*** | 2.95** | 2.86** | 8.77*** | 3.59*** | 0.97ns |
Location (L) | 6 | 401*** | 37.3*** | 175*** | 119*** | 108*** | 403*** | 343*** | 134*** | 48.9*** |
Year (Y) | 1 | 7.4** | 30.3*** | 88.3*** | 376*** | 77.6*** | 23.9*** | 107*** | 0.50ns | 0.73ns |
L*Y | 3 | 308*** | 55.9*** | 9.47*** | 242*** | 173*** | 48.5*** | 114*** | 59.6*** | 32.5*** |
Variety (V) | 5 | 57.9*** | 45.2*** | 11.05*** | 45.1*** | 17.6*** | 33.0*** | 108*** | 29.0*** | 7.78*** |
T | 1 | 30.5*** | 9.37** | 1.57ns | 40.3*** | 10.9** | 153*** | 60.4*** | 66.8*** | 107*** |
V*T | 5 | 7.60*** | 5.57*** | 4.49*** | 12.5*** | 1.09ns | 41.3*** | 33.1*** | 6.43*** | 4.01** |
V*L | 30 | 3.60*** | 3.67*** | 4.12*** | 4.83*** | 3.65*** | 2.84*** | 4.06*** | 2.28** | 1.80* |
T*L | 6 | 1.46ns | 1.45ns | 4.69*** | 6.43*** | 0.40ns | 2.53* | 1.38ns | 3.72** | 3.18** |
V*Y | 5 | 4.18** | 2.23ns | 3.28** | 1.11ns | 5.42*** | 6.96*** | 1.81ns | 7.58*** | 2.89* |
T*Y | 1 | 0.15ns | 6.99** | 0.04ns | 0.17ns | 0.13ns | 4.13* | 0.06ns | 18.96*** | 28.9*** |
T*L*Y | 3 | 3.13* | 3.51* | 1.53ns | 2.08ns | 4.58* | 0.12ns | 2.86* | 0.91ns | 0.86ns |
Discussion. Table 3 lists a summary of the data on the T1BL·1RS translocation from relevant papers over the last decade. Only those traits are listed that were investigated in our experiment. First, the table shows whether or not the studies were made with the use of NILs or with lines/varieties that differed only in the presence or absence of the translocation. The results are presented only by indicating whether or not the translocation lines were superior or inferior when compared to their respective lines lacking T1BL·1RS. For example, Villareal et al. (1991) found that the translocation lines had a higher 1,000-kernel weight when compared to genotypes lacking T1BL·1RS. The difference was highly significant and is indicated by +***. The list has two exceptions where obviously no difference was found in most studies similar results were obtained. Accordingly, 1,000-kernel weight is probably the main cause for the higher yield of the translocation lines. Another interesting result was obtained for protein content. No correlation seems to exist among the uniform inferiority of the translocation lines for Zeleny sedimentation value, SDS sedimentation, and SDS-gel protein. Obviously, the reduced bread-making quality of the translocation lines is not correlated with protein content.
Our results on the six pairs of NILs are very much in line with previously published data on the contrasting effect of the T1BL·1RS translocation on the yield and quality of wheat. The highly significant 'genotype x translocation' interaction (Table 2) also agrees with the observation of background effects on the phenotypic expression of 1RS (Carver and Rayburn 1994, Villareal et al. 1995). In addition, the higher environmental stability of the translocation lines in comparison to those where it is lacking is underlined by a nonsignificant interaction for yield of the translocation lines.
Schlegel and Korzun (1997) pointed out that because of the single origin the 1RS arm of most T1BL·1RS translocation lines in the world possess no allelic variation. At present, the advantage of this rye chromosome arm can be exploited only by selecting the appropriate wheat background. Methods have been suggested by Lelley et al. (2000) for the introduction of new allelic variation into 1RS by homologous recombination.
Acknowledgments. We gratefully acknowledge the kind cooperation of the following organizations for their help with the field experiments: Versuchsstation Univerität Bodenkultur, Großenzersdorf; Saatbau Linz, Reichersberg; Saatzucht Edelhof; Bundesamt und Forschungszentrum für Landwirtschaft, Wien Aussenstelle Grabenegg und Petzenkirchen; and the Cereal Research Non-Profit Company, Szeged Hungary.
References.
Sabine Grausgruber-Gröger and Tamas Lelley.
Crosses between Austrian, Hungarian, and Croatian winter wheat genotypes were made to study the influence of the Glu-1, Glu-3, and Gli-1 loci on bread-making quality. Double haploid lines were developed using the 'wheat x maize' system. Protein alleles were identified by using SDS- and A-PAGE. A selection of lines was used to study the effect of the protein-coding genes on bread-making quality in an orthogonal fashion. Quality was determined by grain-protein content and the Zeleny sedimentation volume. Analysis of variance revealed the influence of the different loci on bread-making quality.
Among 1,110 DH lines, no recombination between the Gli-1 and Glu-3 alleles was found. In two crosses between genotypes with and without the T1BL·1RS translocation, lines were detected containing neither Gli-B1/Glu-B3 proteins nor secalins. In one cross, it could be shown that this was due to a deletion in the distal region of chromosome 1RS. The presence of T1B·1RS had a negative effect on the sedimentation volume in some crosses. The deletion lines revealed that in these lines the presence of the secalins had a more negative effect than the loss of the Gli-B1/Glu-B3 proteins. The effect of T1BL·1RS seems to depend on the genetic background.
The greatest effect on sedimentation volume was observed for Glu-D1. In some crosses, the effects of Gli-A1/Glu-A3 and Gli-B1/Glu-B3 were of the same order as those of Glu-A1 and Glu-B1. From the results, we ranked the loci with respects to their effect on Zeleny sedimentation value. To name the gliadin and low molecular weight glutenin alleles in the loci Gli-1 and Glu-3, respectively, the nomenclature of Jackson et al. (1996) was followed.
Glu-A1: 2* > 1 Glu-B1: 7+8 > 7+9 Glu-D1: 5+10 > 2+12, 5+10 > 5*+12 Gli-A1/Glu-A3: o/2 > l/1, b/3 > 5/a, a/6 > 8/9 Gli-B1/Glu-B3: f/fg > 4/d Gli-D1/Glu-D3: k/c > b/a
Significant effects of alleles at the locus Gli-1/Glu-3 were found, although the D-zone gliadins could not be differentiated. The D-zone gliadins alone do not seem to be sufficient for differentiating quality. Although some alleles were present in several crosses, their effects on sedimentation volume and protein content were not constant. Therefore, interactions appear to exist between the diverse loci and alleles and the genetic background. Although the separation of gliadins using A-PAGE was simple, the separation of LMW glutenins required a laborious extraction procedure.
Determining the allele content of the Gli-1 and Glu-3 loci was only partly successful. The Gli-1 alleles could be easily identified if they occurred in the upper part of the gel. The T1BL·1RS translocation was clearly seen in A-PAGE. The analysis of Glu-3 alleles was hampered by the many bands of very similar molecular weight. The unsystematic appearance of the gliadin and LMW-glutenin bands suggested that they probably were coded for by loci other than Gli-1, Gli-2, and Glu-3.
For practical breeding, both the identification of HMW-glutenin alleles and the presence and/or absence of the T1BL·1RS translocation in the crossing partners can be recommended. Early testing for sedimentation value of bread-making quality seems to be the simplest and a most reliable approach. The knowledge of the effects of Gli-1/Glu-3 alleles on quality parameters gained in this study and available in the literature does not allow us to recommend their systematic selection in practical breeding,
References.
UNIVERSITY OF AGRICULTURAL SCIENCES VIENNA
Department of Plant Breeding, Gregor Mendel Str. 33, A 1180 Vienna, Austria.
Salih Salihi, Heinrich Grausgruber, Roman Tumpold, and Peter Ruckenbauer.
A set of 75 winter wheats was grown in 199900 at the University of Prishtina (in cooperation with Prof. S. Fetahu) for evaluation under Kosovan growing conditions. The trial was initiated in order to establish knowledge on field experiments and to find out genotypes that could be used for biparental crosses at the beginning of a wheat breeding program.
The material consisted of genotypes from Austria, central and eastern Europe, the U.S.A., and CIMMYT. All but the Austrian wheats were donated by CIMMYT, Ankara, Tukey. Sowing was by hand in mid-October. Plot size was 15 sq m. The experiment was an RCBD with three replicates. However, the trial was analyzed as a row-column design in order to control spatial variation. Composite samples over the replicates were used for quality evaluations, which were estimations of the protein content by NIRS and dough extension tests using a SMS Texture Analyzer TA.XT2i® with the Kieffer dough and gluten extensibility rigs.
The highest yielding genotypes originated from Turkey, Ukraine, Hungary, and diverse CIMMYT programs. The Austrian cultivars performed only average. However, the Austrian cultivars showed the highest protein contents. The dough extension tests revealed several genotypes with very weak and/or very strong dough characteristics. This strenghtening and/or weakening effect was probably due to heat stress during grain filling.